The
endorsed the following positions in the prior election:

REALITY CHECK:
Ballot Measures  November 2, 1999 Election � Vote- By-Mail

WON

68 YES Changes inmate work program (sponsored by Senator Susan Castillo & Senate Minority Leader Kate Brown) 

REALITY: Measure fixes problems in inmate work program mandate.

The "Mannix Seven"

WON

69

NO

Amends Constitution: Supposedly grants victims constitutional rights in criminal prosecutions. 

REALITY: Victims already have these rights under Oregon law. Prosecutor will pick who the victim is. Victims have no right to enforce this so-called "constitutional" right.

LOST

70

NO

Amends Constitution: Gives public, through prosecutor, right to demand jury trial in criminal cases. 

REALITY: Prosecutor can ignore victim (as well as defendant and judge) who does not want to have jury trial (for example: sensational sex crime;  DA with political aspirations).

WON

71

NO

Amends Constitution: Limits pretrial release of accused persons. 

REALITY: Current law provides protection against release of persons accused of violent crimes. Assumes person is guilty if arrested. Costs taxpayers millions for jail space that does not currently exist. Revokes fundamental tenet of legal tradition going back hundreds of years.

LOST

72

NO

Amends Constitution: Allows murder conviction by 11 to 1 jury. 

REALITY: Currently, murder conviction requires unanimous decision by jury. This is contrary to proof of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Increases likelihood of more innocent people found guilty. Louisiana is the only state that allows murder conviction by less than 12-0. Juries virtually never hang 11-1; nearly always by a higher ratio. A radical change to a fundamental concept of our legal system whose roots in English common law go back to the Fourteenth Century!

LOST

73

NO

Amends Constitution: Limits immunity from criminal prosecution of persons ordered to testify about conduct. 

REALITY: Gives state and local prosecutors same kind of unbridled power that special prosecutor Ken Starr used against Susan McDougal. Erodes constitutional protection against self-incrimination. Revokes a fundamental tenet of legal tradition going back hundreds of years.

WON

74

NO

Amends Constitution: Requires terms of imprisonment announced in court to be fully served, with rare exceptions. 

REALITY: Takes away power from the people and the legislature to change bad sentencing laws. Prohibits release of prisoner if gravely ill even if victim agrees to release. 

WON

75

NO

Amends Constitution: Persons convicted of certain crimes cannot serve on grand juries, criminal trial juries. 

REALITY: Bars persons convicted of felony within last 15 years or "dishonest" or "violent" misdemeanor within last 5 years from serving on criminal juries. Requires state to background check everyone called to jury duty or requires persons to self-report.


WON

76

no

position

Requires cost of roads be split fairly between car & truck drivers. 

Special thanks to ROPNET for permission to adapt their webpage arguments for this page.
Their original arguments can be found at
http://www.rdrop.com/users/batie/ropnet.html

QUESTIONS? Contact the DPLC: Telephone: (541) 484-5099 e-mail: [email protected]

last updated on 03 Dec 1999